Phones answered 24/7Fort Collins, CO
Call (833) 490-5225
Guide

Why Old Town Basements Flood in Heavy Rain

Why Old Town Fort Collins basements back up in heavy rain: an older storm sewer system, a 2,120-acre basin, and what city documents have recorded about it.

Illustration for the guide "Why Old Town Basements Flood in Heavy Rain" (Fort Collins, CO)
Short answer

Old Town basements flood because the oldest part of Fort Collins drains through a storm sewer system built for far less water than a big thunderstorm delivers. City documents have recorded that drains in the older basins were sufficient at best for a two-year storm, so surface water ponds and finds the lowest opening.

Key takeaways

  • City documents have recorded that storm sewers in the older Fort Collins basins were sufficient at best for a two-year storm, which is a modest rainfall, not a rare one.
  • The Old Town basin covers about 2,120 acres, so water that falls streets away from your house can still arrive at your foundation wall.
  • A 2002 master plan for the basin estimated that 620 structures would be damaged in a 100-year event.
  • A June 1992 storm flooded 51 home basements and 16 businesses, which is the kind of event these drains were never sized for.
  • Much of Old Town dates from the early twentieth century and earlier, so foundations, floor drains and buried laterals are often older than any current standard.
  • The city's flood brochure advises building 18 inches above the 100-year flood elevation, which is a useful benchmark when you are deciding what to put in a basement.

What is actually undersized in Old Town, the pipe or the rain?

Both, in a sense. The rain is ordinary for the Front Range, and the pipe is old. City documents have recorded that the storm sewers serving the older basins were sufficient at best for a two-year storm, which a single strong summer cell can beat.

A storm sewer is designed to a storm, not to all storms. Engineers pick a design event, size the pipes for it and accept that anything bigger will run on the surface instead. In the oldest parts of Fort Collins that design event is small by modern standards: a hazard-mitigation application recorded that the drains in the older basins were sufficient at best for a two-year storm. A two-year storm is not a disaster, it is a rainfall you would expect to see more than once in a decade.

So the honest way to describe an Old Town street in a heavy cell is not that the drainage failed. It is that the drainage reached its capacity and the rest of the water stayed on the ground, flowing downhill along gutters, alleys and driveways until it found the lowest opening in its path. On a block of houses built a century ago, that opening is often a window well, an areaway door, a coal-chute patch or a stairwell down to a basement entrance.

How big is the Old Town drainage basin?

The Old Town basin covers about 2,120 acres. That matters because the water that reaches your foundation did not necessarily fall on your lot; it fell somewhere in a basin of that size and traveled to the lowest point it could reach.

Homeowners usually think about their own roof and their own yard, and in a basin this large that is the smaller half of the problem. Rain landing on roofs, streets, alleys, parking areas and compacted yards several blocks uphill has to go somewhere, and in an older grid it goes along the street surface. A house that sits a little low on its block, or at the bottom of a short grade, collects the contributions of everything above it.

This is why two neighbors can have very different flooding histories with identical construction. One sits a few inches higher, or its driveway slopes away, or its alley drains the other direction. When we are called out to a wet basement in Old Town, the first thing worth walking is not the basement but the block: where water enters the property, where it ponds, and whether the grade at the foundation sends it away or holds it.

Has Fort Collins recorded how many Old Town buildings are at risk?

Yes. A 2002 master plan for the Old Town basin estimated that 620 structures would be damaged in a 100-year event. These documents are dated, so treat the number as the city's recorded estimate from that study rather than a current count.

That estimate is useful less as a prediction than as a measure of exposure. It tells you that basement and ground-floor flooding in the old core is a known, mapped, studied problem with a large number of buildings inside the affected footprint, not a run of bad luck at individual addresses. It also explains why the city has spent decades on stormwater work: the Stormwater Utility was created in 1980, and floodplain regulations were adopted in 1979 when the city joined the National Flood Insurance Program.

If you own in the old core, the practical move is to ask the city directly about your own address rather than reason from a basin-wide figure. Fort Collins Utilities holds the floodplain status of specific properties, and our guide on whether your home is in a floodplain walks through what that answer does and does not tell you about rain-driven basement flooding, which is a different hazard from river flooding.

What happened in the June 1992 storm?

A June 1992 storm flooded 51 home basements and 16 businesses in Fort Collins. It is a useful reference point because it was a rainfall event, not a river flood, and the damage pattern was basements and ground floors rather than washed-out roads.

Fifty-one basements in one storm is the signature of a drainage system at capacity across a wide area at once. Had this been a single blocked inlet or one broken lateral, the damage would have clustered on one street. Spread across dozens of homes and more than a dozen businesses, it points at surface water everywhere, moving downhill in parallel, entering wherever the lowest opening happened to be.

That has a practical consequence that surprises people after the fact. In a storm of that kind, restoration crews are dealing with many properties on the same night, and water is still arriving while the first extraction starts. Crews are dispatched around the clock as fast as one becomes available, and the hour before a crew arrives is yours to use: kill power to the wet area at the breaker if you can do it from dry footing, move what you can lift, and photograph the water line before anything is moved.

Why does the age of Old Town housing matter to a wet basement?

Much of Old Town dates from the early twentieth century and earlier, and the district has been on the National Register of Historic Places since 1978. Older foundations, floor drains and buried connections behave differently in a flood than modern ones.

A century-old foundation is usually a more porous assembly than a recent one: stone or early concrete, mortar joints that have been repointed in patches, and no modern damp-proofing membrane on the outside face. Water standing against that wall for an hour does not need a crack to get in. It wicks through the material itself and shows up as a dark band low on the wall rather than a stream at one point, which is why a basement can be wet with no visible hole to blame.

The buildings themselves are part of what makes the drying job different. Old Town's architecture is mainly Late Victorian and Romanesque, and in a historic district the finishes are frequently worth saving: lath and plaster, original trim, wood floors over a crawl area, built-in cabinetry. Those assemblies hold water inside cavities and under finishes, and they dry slowly, so the work leans on structural drying and dehumidification with moisture readings over several days instead of the quick demolition that a modern finished basement would get.

Is it rainwater or sewage coming up the floor drain?

Treat it as contaminated until you know. A floor drain that is pushing water upward during a storm is carrying water from the system, not from your house, and the safe assumption in an older neighborhood is that it may contain sewage.

The difference decides everything about the cleanup. Clean rainwater that entered through a window well can often be extracted and dried with the contents kept in place. Water that came up through a drain is handled as a contaminated loss: porous materials that absorbed it, including carpet, pad, cardboard and the lower part of drywall, usually come out, and hard surfaces are cleaned and disinfected rather than just dried. That is the scope of a sewer backup cleanup, and it is not a judgment you want to make by smell alone after the fact.

Tell the restoration crew what you saw and when, because the entry route is reconstructed from your account and from the staining. Where the water came up the drain and also came in at a window, both have to be in the file, since an insurer will treat those two causes differently. Our basement flooding after heavy rain page sets out how that scope is built.

Can old pipes flood a building in winter, not just in storms?

Yes. In December 2019 a roughly 90-year-old water main on Jefferson Street froze and ruptured, flooding about a dozen businesses and City Hall. Buried infrastructure of that age is a flooding source in its own right, separate from rain.

That event is worth knowing about if you own an older commercial building downtown, because the water did not arrive from the sky or from a creek. It came from a main under the street, and the buildings affected were the ones nearest to it and lowest. Nothing a tenant does to their own plumbing changes that exposure, which is why downtown businesses benefit from knowing in advance where their own shutoff is and which part of their floor is the low corner.

For practical purposes it also means the flooding season in the old core never really closes. Summer brings surface water the drains cannot take; winter brings freeze damage to pipes in unheated spaces and, occasionally, to the mains themselves. Our guide on frozen pipes in a Fort Collins cold snap covers the building-side version of that problem in detail.

What should an Old Town owner actually change?

Work on the water's route rather than on the basement finish. Grading, downspout discharge, window well covers and what you store below grade all change the outcome more cheaply than anything you can install after the water is already inside.

Start outside. Downspouts that end at the foundation are the most common avoidable contributor we see, and extending them so they discharge well away from the wall costs little. Window wells in the old core are often shallow and sit below the surrounding grade; a cover and a clear gravel base keep them from becoming a funnel. Grade that has settled toward the house over decades is worth rebuilding, and in an alley-served block it is worth checking where the alley drains before you assume the street is the problem.

Inside, the decision is about what lives below grade. The city's flood brochure advises building 18 inches above the 100-year flood elevation, and that benchmark translates usefully to a basement: keep the furnace controls, the electrical panel, stored papers and anything irreplaceable off the floor and up the wall. If you want a finished basement in a house from this era, build it so it can be dried rather than demolished: inorganic flooring, removable base trim, and a wall assembly that does not trap water at the bottom plate. Call (833) 490-5225 if you need an opinion on a basement that has flooded more than once.

Frequently asked questions

Does a storm sewer upgrade mean my basement is safe now?

No single upgrade makes a basement safe, and the city's work is a long program rather than one project. Since 1990 the city has built channel and floodplain improvements to a 100-year design and taken a number of properties out of the hazard area, which reduces exposure where it applies. It does not change the capacity of every older drain, and it does nothing about water entering at your own window well or downspout. Treat public improvements and private measures as two separate layers.

Why did my neighbor stay dry when I flooded in the same storm?

Almost always elevation and route. A few inches of difference in where the house sits on the block, which way the driveway slopes, how the alley drains and whether the downspouts discharge away from the wall decide where surface water goes. In a basin of about 2,120 acres the water is looking for the lowest opening on its way downhill, and it only takes one property to be that opening. Construction being identical does not make the exposure identical.

Is a sump pump worth installing in an Old Town basement?

It depends on where the water is coming from, which is why the entry route is worth establishing before you spend anything. A pump handles water that rises into a pit from below or seeps through the floor and walls. It does nothing useful about a stream pouring down a basement stairwell from the street, and it will be overwhelmed by a backed-up drain. If a pump is already fitted and failed during a storm, that is a different loss again, covered on our sump pump failure page.

How long does drying a historic basement take?

Longer than a modern one, and the equipment usually stays in place for several days with readings taken each visit. Plaster, old wood and stone hold water inside the assembly and release it slowly, and pulling equipment out when the surface feels dry is the mistake that leads to a mold call a few weeks later. The honest answer for any individual basement comes from meter readings over time, not from a schedule written in advance.

Does the historic district restrict what can be done during a repair?

Old Town has been on the National Register of Historic Places since 1978, and in a district of that status the character of what is visible from the street matters to the city. Emergency water removal and drying are not the issue; replacement of exterior features can be. If a loss takes you into exterior repair, ask the city about the review that applies to your address before ordering materials, because that answer is address-specific and we do not guess at it.

What should I photograph before a crew arrives?

The water line on the wall, the standing water with something in the frame for scale, the ceiling or floor directly above and below the wet area, any drain that is backing up, and the outside of the house where water is entering. Add a short written note of the time the water appeared and what the weather was doing. That set answers most of what an adjuster asks later, and it cannot be recreated once the extraction starts.

Sources

  1. City of Fort Collins
  2. City of Fort Collins history

This guide is general information for Larimer County homeowners, not a substitute for an on-site inspection. Prices are estimates. See our disclaimer.

Need help today?

Call any hour and explain what is going on. You get a clear price before any work starts.

Keep reading

More guides

Is my Fort Collins home in a floodplain?

Fort Collins Utilities holds floodplain status for a specific property, and that is where the question is settled rather than by a neighbor or a listing.

WhatsApp